[Voting] Freestyle Signature

[Eve]

• Voting begins Aug 12 and ends Aug 16.
  
• First to reach 15 votes, or highest in 4 days.
  
• Contestants may vote, but not for themselves.
  
• Be constructive with comments, these are beginners.
  

Good luck to all contestants!

[Untouch]

Good Luck to everyone who entered.
I can tell right away which one is yours Bkotz.

[awil]

Haha..Me also can tell which one is bkotz's sig too..

[Nemmyy]

1) Made me laugh
2) Too plain, I don't really like the text either
3) Looks pretty cool but I'm not sure what the white lines are and the text is bad
4) Best overall, good lighting, blending, and use of C4Ds

[Daniel Faraday]

I voted for #1.

1
It was very simple, but the best out of all of them IMO.

2
The text was bad.
There weren't many effects or good lighting.

3
Too blurry.
The lines are a negative as well.

4
I had to get pretty close to the screen just to make out what was the render and what was the C4D,
The background doesn't really blend with the render or the C4D.
The light on the his back is unneeded.

The only thing I don't like about the background is the right side.
It throws off the piece IMO.

[Fragma]

I apologize for my previous post. It wasn't very helpful so heres some constructive criticism for each of the signatures.

Voted 4 because it is slightly more professional than the others. Although it could do with better blending.

I like the idea of number 1. Although I think it could do without the black background.

Number 2 needs more creativity. You should use more effects, brushes & try to create a main focal point. Also try experimenting with different texts that suit the rest of the signature.

Number 3 has potential. You should practice blending more & work on lighting techniques.

I hope you can all take some of this advice on board and progress in the future.

[Daniel Faraday]

It's called "freestyle" for a reason .

[bkotz]

Good luck everyone
may the best sig win

[Minus-Zero]

I voted for number 4 obviously the most well done.

[Kanee]

I voted 4, because it looks the most professionally done.