I like the theme and the idea has potential, but I personally don't think it'll interest many people honestly. Many members seem to have joined because they know you from HF/MF. That is not bad, but some people may only join to suck up to you.
Edit:
After more reviewing, I do like the idea. However, you are attracting a HORRIBLE crowd. Notice how you have 500 posts in one day? People are joining and posting very stupid threads. I'm unsure if you want that, but if you are aiming for high quality and interesting discussions you cannot publicly advertise it on places like HF.
Edit:
After more reviewing, I do like the idea. However, you are attracting a HORRIBLE crowd. Notice how you have 500 posts in one day? People are joining and posting very stupid threads. I'm unsure if you want that, but if you are aiming for high quality and interesting discussions you cannot publicly advertise it on places like HF.