Cod 4 or Halo 3

[Maine]

you really cannot compare these two games.Both have there cons and there strong areas.
at this time halo was more mainstream for Xbox which i think mainly everyone had at the time.I personally like cod 4 more though due to the fact i never played halo in my life,i always pictured it as 7 year olds shooting aliens and crap.
I'm willing to give halo a chance probably getting reach soon if black ops didn't suck the life out of it already.

Reach sucks though. Halo 3 was 100% better.

---

To be honest, I would say it would be more of a competition if you went with Halo 2. Halo 2 was by far better, but with Halo 3 versus CoD 4, I would say Call of Duty was better. It was the only Call of Duty game that could actually make me think that Halo wasn't as fun. With any other CoD game, I would shift back to Halo within an hour or two. CoD 4 is most definitely the best game that I have played from the series in general as well.

I agree also, halo 2 is better. But Halo 3 and Cod 4 came out around the same time.