+- Support Forums (https://www.supportforums.net)
+-- Forum: Categories (https://www.supportforums.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=87)
+--- Forum: Life Support (https://www.supportforums.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=12)
+---- Forum: Graphic Design and Tutorials (https://www.supportforums.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=23)
+---- Thread: Rate SupportForums logo/signature :) (/showthread.php?tid=17731)
RE: Rate SupportForums logo/signature :) - Elitestate - 04-06-2011
I rate it.. 4/10 Very basic stuff you've done there, there also to big for how a normal logo or sig should be
RE: Rate SupportForums logo/signature :) - Stiggie - 04-06-2011
I think they are very good. Keep it up, maybe some of you'r work, will be at the top.
RE: Rate SupportForums logo/signature :) - John* - 04-06-2011
Thank you Elitestate for the rate and The stig for the perfect comment. Will try to make the first one looks better.
RE: Rate SupportForums logo/signature :) - panDa. - 04-06-2011
- Not fitting SF Theme
- Bad Colors
- Bad Lightining on First Image
- Bad Texture on first image
- Stroke is awful on second image
- Text's don't fit backgrounds
- No effects in background
= TOO SIMPLE
RE: Rate SupportForums logo/signature :) - Justin - 04-06-2011
(04-06-2011, 12:40 PM)panDa. Wrote: - Not fitting SF Theme
- Bad Colors
- Bad Lightining on First Image
- Bad Texture on first image
- Stroke is awful on second image
- Text's don't fit backgrounds
- No effects in background
= TOO SIMPLE
100% agree with this post.
RE: Rate SupportForums logo/signature :) - John* - 04-06-2011
Ahh, guys i know it isn't perfect but i posted it here to see your rates. So please rate, thanks for the comments anyway.
RE: Rate SupportForums logo/signature :) - mycroft - 04-06-2011
Seems like an Effect from GIMP.
Well, I rate it 8/10
1. You used mostly generated ones
2. Is that rust? It seems like something was put there.
RE: Rate SupportForums logo/signature :) - John* - 04-07-2011
Thank you mycroft for the rate, but can you tell me your rate was for first or second image?
RE: Rate SupportForums logo/signature :) - Nickpooz - 04-07-2011
honestly i think its to flashy, I would rate this 6/10 sorry.
RE: Rate SupportForums logo/signature :) - John* - 04-07-2011
Thank you for the vote Nickpooz, i appreciate it ;)