This is my first ever signature using a C4D or render (in other words, my first ever signature that's not just transparent background text):
Update:
Be honest, not nice.
It's not too bad. The background is really plain and I don't like either of the texts, try to find a shade/gradient somewhere in between the two you tried.
Its not bad at all. I think its really good. Compared to mine, i give you a 5/5
Looks ok but a little not basic!
Thank you all for the feedback, I appreciate it.
Its Your First Signature Right I Give 7/10, Becasue Its Too Simple Needs Effect And Much More.
You need to blend more, better background.
I like the text blend a bit, but it's still very basic.
Needs to have some more effects, and the text looks out of place. The render could be blended better too.
For a first signature though, I'll give it a 6/10.
You need to work on blending and not putting "bevel and emboss" on the text. But It's not bad for a first attempt. 6/10.
The render doesn't blend in at all.
The background is poor.
Barely any effects so it's not attractive to look at.
Text is ok for a first real signature but in general is bad.
Overall decent for a first signature but now go away read lots of tutorials, learn the basics and make many more signatures.